MET COAL SERIES: Metallurgical coal's gradual change of guard in spot market influence

Banner Image

This five-part story series examines the coking coal market from a few angles. This first part focuses on pricing evolution and spot liquidity. The second analyzes how trade flows have changed, the third traces the rising importance of environment, social and governance criteria, while the fourth takes a deep dive into the workings of coal trading platforms that may inform spot price assessments. The final part examines the current state of the spot market and explores directions for future evolution.

Shifts in the way a commodity is priced often result from major economic and world events and coking coal is no exception, having witnessed the pricing mechanism for long-term contracts move from annual negotiations toward spot-linked pricing over 2010-2012 as spot prices crashed due to a sovereign debt crisis in Europe, a shaky US recovery from the 2008 global financial crisis and China's sagging under the weight of ballooning domestic steel capacity.

While earlier annual benchmark negotiations were led mainly by major steelmakers in Japan and Europe, Chinese steelmakers had an increasing say through their activity in spot markets as growing steel capacity fueled their appetite for coking coal imports.

More than a decade on, the coking coal market has not looked back on its price indexation journey, although a new set of events – the pandemic, China's unofficial ban on Australian coal, erratic weather and the Russia-Ukraine war – may see a change of guard in terms of spot market activity, chiefly by India and Russia.

Brave old world

The path that coking coal embarked on in its indexation journey is a well-trodden one. Not only did iron ore pave the way a couple of years earlier, when then BHP Billiton CEO Marius Kloppers broke away from the annual benchmark system in favor of spot pricing – many other commodity markets effectively already had some form of floating price mechanism in place based on published price indices, including assessments published by Platts, part of S&P Global Commodity Insights.

While vestiges remain, as in the case of some semi-soft coal and pulverized coal injection contracts which are set via quarterly negotiated fixed prices in Northeast Asia, the wave of indexation has been inexorable.

The implicit understanding in the coking coal market was that BHP, as the biggest producer of coking coal, would dedicate a portion of output to the spot market to support price discovery, whether via bilateral negotiations or on trading platforms.

This unspoken compact was broadly seen to have served the market well, as long as a steady stream of spot supply flowed and allowed daily supply-demand fundamentals to determine where prices were assessed and published, which when averaged, let buyers and sellers effectively do away with long-drawn price negotiations.

The stage was therefore set, with one of the key conditions in the evolution of any commodity market toward proper price risk management fulfilled. The other key condition is the growth of a corresponding paper market for market participants to hedge their price exposure or speculate on future price directions.

Today, the metallurgical coal market has made inroads in index-linked pricing but is yet to see the derivative market develop to a meaningful size for efficient hedging and speculation.

Market participants see the low liquidity in the derivative market as a barrier to entry, although a chicken-and-egg problem presents in that some cite the low liquidity as precisely the reason why they are not entering the paper market.

China held sway as top buyer

Before China's unofficial ban on Australian coal imports in October 2020, it was the biggest spot buyer of seaborne metallurgical coal.

Leaning on rich domestic coal resources, Chinese buyers often tapped imports of seaborne coals opportunistically, especially premium brands with high coke strength after reaction and low volatile matter that served the needs of the ever-growing sizes of their blast furnaces, especially in coastal regions.

Chinese buyers were often seen as price leaders by buyers in the rest of the world, and deals, bids and offers they were involved in informed Platts CFR China assessments. Often, but not automatically, such information also informed Platts assessments on an FOB Australia basis via a freight netback, when it was determined that China was the marginal buyer of coals traded on this incoterm.

Not everyone, however, was thrilled with the idea of the Chinese market setting prices for the rest of the Asia-Pacific and even as far afield as Europe, where buying practices differed drastically.

Steelmakers in these so-called traditional markets operate mostly older coke- and iron-making facilities that limit flexibility in coal blending, and so prefer to lock in nearly all their requirements via term contracts to ensure security of supply.

Following China's unofficial ban on Australian coal imports, two key changes occurred. The first was the decoupling of the relationship between FOB Australia and CFR China prices.

The spread between Platts Premium Low Vol Hard Coking Coal CFR China and FOB Australia prices in 2019 averaged at $9.31/mt, according to S&P Global calculations.

This was very close to the average of Platts dry bulk freight assessments for metallurgical coal for the East Coast Australia-Northern China route over the same year, at $9.45/mt, indicating how closely related prices on both locational bases are.

But from November 2020 onwards, the CFR-FOB spread has widened in both directions, surging to a high of $218/mt in October 2021 after major rains flooded coal mines in the key province of Shanxi, and then plunging to minus $245/mt in March 2022 after the EU threatened to sanction Russian coal.

The market has not been a stranger to this phenomenon, as seen when Cyclone Debbie hit in 2017, which saw FOB Australia prices surge far above CFR China price levels.

Plunge in spot liquidity

The second major change was the sharp drop in spot liquidity observed, as steelmakers in other major importing economies like Europe, India and other parts of Northeast Asia willingly took up the coal that the Chinese gave up, not surprisingly, mainly via term contracts.

Spot transactions for premium hard coking coals on a CFR China basis observed by Platts slumped to just 4.12 million mt in 2021 from 27.32 million mt the previous year, and dropped further to 0.73 million mt in 2022, data compiled by Platts showed.

As a percentage of total output by BHP Mitsubishi Alliance (BMA), the world's top producer, Platts-observed spot deals of premium hard coking coals were at 19% in 2020, slipped to 13% the following year and then tumbled to just 6% in 2022.

In the first three months of 2023, observed spot deals accounted for 6% of BMA's production, indicating little change in the trend of thinning spot liquidity.

BHP, which markets all the coal produced by the joint venture, did not respond to an e-mailed request for comment.

The increased allocation of material to term contracts compounded a situation of reduced spot availability in 2022, when planned EU sanctions on Russian coal, inclement weather in Queensland that curtailed output and COVID-19-related labor shortages drove spot prices to a record high of $670.50/mt FOB Australia in March.

Even though term contracts ensured security of supply, spot-linked pricing meant that any tightness in spot material reverberated and was magnified in the price of term contractual volumes.

Enter India

Steelmakers in India, having undergone consolidations and all executing ambitious capacity expansions, comprised a key market segment that actively boosted term contractual purchasing, mainly due to a lack of domestic resources.

Leapfrogging China as the top importer of seaborne coking coal last year and being agnostic to Western sanctions on Russian coal and PCI, Indian steelmakers have come into their own and are now playing a more active role in the spot market.

When converting coal to coke did not make economic sense, JSW Steel for example sought to sell coking coal via real-time transparent tenders published by Platts, following a similar move by ArcelorMittal.

Indian buyers have also moved beyond being buyers of mainly mid-tier hard coking coals to become active buyers of premium hard coking coals from Australia and even North America.

What has driven their new-found appetite has been a tectonic shift in seaborne coking coal trade flows that has seen attractively priced Russian mid-tier coals being redirected by the Russia-Ukraine war to willing buyers mainly in India and China.

From a benchmarking perspective, India's emerging activity in the spot market for premium low-vol hard coking coals may see it exert greater influence over corresponding price assessments for that grade of coal, especially as it competes head-to-head with Chinese mills as the marginal buyer of Australian coals.

The next part of the series examines more closely the shifts in these trade flows and their impact.

Related content

News

Italian battery market slowed in first quarter: ANIE

Battery additions down from Q4 2023 Number of installations increases Lithium hydroxide contract softens Italian additions of battery storage capacity in the first quarter declined by 8% quarter on quarter, and were below Q1 2023 levels, industry group ANIE Federazione said in its latest report June 6. Additions across the first quarter totaled 440 MW, down 38 MW from Q4 2024 and significantly below the 594 MW installed in the same period of last year, ANIE data showed. The association attributed the fall to a sharp decline in the residential segment, despite an overall increase in the number of installations as the last beneficiaries of the Superbonus scheme were still receiving credits, according to ANIE. Large-scale utilities offset the drop, with four standalone batteries of 70-88 MW capacity coming into operation during the first quarter. Italy had 593,330 battery installations as of March 31, totaling 3.9 GW of capacity and capable of injecting 7.9 GWh. Italy’s Energy and Climate Plan has set a target of 6 GW by 2030. Almost the entirety of this is lithium-based and is connected to solar PV plants, and 98% of them have capacity of less than 20 kW. Platts, part of S&P Global Commodity Insights, last assessed lithium hydroxide, used in batteries, at $14,000/mt CIF North Asia June 7, after averaging $14,414/mt throughout May. Lombardy is the region with the largest number of systems installed (108,590), followed by Veneto (76,094) and Emilia-Romagna (57,486). Platts Connect: News & Insights (spglobal.com)

News

Walkabout Resources ships first graphite concentrate from Lindi Jumbo in Tanzania

Concentrate shipped to Wogen Pacific under offtake First sale part of larger order from European end-customer Lindi Jumbo to produce 40,000 mt/year of graphite concentrate Graphite miner Walkabout Resources has produced and shipped the first consignment of on-specification graphite concentrate from the Lindi Jumbo graphite mine in Tanzania, it said June 7. The concentrate, bagged in early May , is being shipped from Dar es Salaam for sale to commodity trader Wogen Pacific under an exclusive five-year sales, purchase and marketing agreement signed in July 2023 , the company said in a statement, adding that the first sale was part of a larger order from an end-customer in Europe. “We now have the opportunity to engage with more end-users as we continue to demonstrate we have a viable product and that we are serious contenders in development of non-Chinese graphite supply,” Walkabout CEO Andrew Cunningham said. The company said the relatively small shipment volume was due to limited plant availability and utilization during the commissioning and early ramp-up phase. It had commissioned all sections of the plant, with the commissioning team focused on improving plant performance, availability and utilization with the aim of running the entire circuit on a more continuous basis, while steadily increasing throughput to reach the planned production volume of 40,000 mt/year, it said. Once the throughput targets have been met, it will focus on the end-to-end optimization of processing circuits to consistently achieve customer product specifications, it said. Currently, any product not meeting specification was reprocessed as determined by the Lindi Jumbo on-site laboratory, the company said. Meanwhile, Walkabout said the mid-May US government announcement of the future imposition of a 25% tariff on Chinese natural graphite had added to market concerns over the security of supply chains after China imposed graphite export restrictions. As a result, there appears to be a widening gap between Chinese domestic and ex-China graphite prices, it said, adding that it had experienced the effect of this in the sales orders received to date. Demand for graphite is currently being driven by the lithium-ion battery market, it said. Platts, part of S&P Global Commodity Insights, assessed natural flake graphite at $420/mt FOB China June 6, down 2.3% since it was launched on March 18. The price reflects the spot value of natural flake graphite with 94%-95% carbon content and minus 100 mesh size delivered to Qingdao port. Platts Connect: News & Insights (spglobal.com)

News

'No speed limits' - German energy sector calls for simpler regulation

BDEW congress sees progress, challenges Focus on renewables, grids, decarbonization Eur721 bil investment needed for 2030 goals Germany's energy industry is calling for simpler regulation to get infrastructure projects off the ground, speakers said at the annual congress of utility association BDEW June 5-6 in Berlin. Sector stakeholders noted progress such as record solar capacity deployment, faster permitting of high-voltage projects as well as framework decisions for a hydrogen pipeline grid, but still regulation was slowing down development. "When it comes to the energy transition we can't afford any speed limits," said Manon van Beek, CEO of Dutch-German grid operator Tennet. The company foresees the need to invest Eur160 billion in the Netherlands and Germany between 2024 and 2033. Returning to overhead cables for the next few high-voltage projects into the 2030s could save Eur20 billion versus costly undergrounding of cables, as currently required, the Tennet CEO said. Tennet in 2023 started construction on the Eur10 billion SuedLink, Germany's single biggest energy transition infrastructure project, set to ease North-South grid bottlenecks from 2028. ET funding proposal Germany needs to invest Eur721 billion in energy transition projects to meet 2030 climate targets, the BDEW said in a joint study with municipal utility association VKU and consultancy Deloitte. The sector is proposing an Energy Transition Fund starting with Eur30 billion to Eur50 billion. "We need a bureaucracy diet," BDEW managing director Kerstin Andreas said, noting over 15,000 norms and regulations specific to the energy sector. "Feasibility must take center stage and complexity must be reduced," she said, opening the congress with the slogan "make it easy together." The association, represents over 2,000 German energy sector companies, used the event to elect EWE's CEO Stefan Dohler as its new president. "We want to make the energy transition a success. At the same time, security of supply must be guaranteed at all times -- and for this we will need backup capacities in the form of hydrogen-capable power plants, combined heat and power plants, and energy storage facilities," Dohler said. Grid expansion and the transition in the transport and heating sector are the key focus for the coming years. "In order to master this extremely demanding transformation process, we need stable framework conditions, a reduction in bureaucracy, and an acceleration of planning and approval processes," the BDEW president said. Required investment to meet 2030 climate targets Eur billions Generation (renewables, H2-ready gas turbines) 353 Transmission grid, pipelines (power, gas) 141 Distribution grids (power, gas) 140 District heating 32 Green gases 23 Energy storage 17 Hydrogen core grid 15 Source: BDEW energy transition monitor (June 2024) Market distortions Elsewhere, faster expansion of solar and wind and slower growth in new energy demand is leading to a sharp rise in hourly negative prices during times of oversupply. The CEO of developer BayWa r.e., Matthias Taft, noted "distortions in the power market" and said more flexibility was needed. "Large batteries don't need subsidies but a clear framework for market integration," Taft said. According to analysts at S&P Global Commodity Insights, the number of negative hourly prices across 10 Western European markets so far this year has quadrupled to over 1,200 hours compared to the same period in 2023, with Iberia a key driver. Some 30 GW of battery storage will be online by the end of 2024, up tenfold since 2019, according to Commodity Insights. Platts Connect: News & Insights (spglobal.com)

News

US hybrid EV market accelerates while battery-electric sales cool

BEV sales up 5%, hybrids up 50% year on year North American lithium investment grows in 2024 While US battery electric vehicle (BEV) sales growth was stagnant in Q1 2024 year on year, a market shake up and better flexibility for consumers drove strong growth in plug-in hybrid electric vehicles (PHEV), according to S&P Global Commodity Insights. In the US, BEV sales are the highest among passenger light duty electric vehicle technology, making up 7.1% of LDVs sold in Q1 2024 and plug-in hybrids accounted for 2.3% of cars sold in the same period, up from 1.6% a year before. The increase in hybrids pushed PHEV sales up 50% year on year in the quarter, while BEVs saw only a 5% increase in Q1. PHEVs flexibility can enable an easier transition for many consumers looking to move off of internal combustion engine vehicles. Fuel type flexibility addresses range anxiety and concerns around charging infrastructure, said Suzanna Massingue, Low Carbon Transportation Analyst at Commodity Insights. “As people in the US gain more awareness of EVs, PHEVs can be a viable first option for the journey away from ICE vehicles,” Massingue said. In the US, Q1 total EV sales totaled 350,572 units, a 22% increase year on year, according to Commodity Insights data. The share of electric and hybrid electric vehicle sales declined in first quarter total US light-duty vehicle sales, according to a May 14 US Energy Information Administration report. The decline was driven by a decrease in BEV sales, which fell from 8.1% to a 7% share of total LDV sales quarter on quarter, the first BEV market share decline since the second quarter of 2020, the EIA said. LDV sales are “highly seasonal” and tend to level off in the first quarter, the EIA stated. Vehicle pricing is a “huge factor” in consumer decision making, particularly as EVs in the US market continue to be more expensive against ICE vehicles, Massingue said. The EV industry is currently facing high rates of inflation, supply chain tensions and a potentially consequential election, she said. “In more mature EV markets, government subsidies have helped to bridge the gap and bring price parity between ICEs and EVs,” Massingue said. “The tax credits brought by the IRA have been criticized for their lack of clarity and limited applicability to vehicles on the market currently, i.e. too few PEVs available today are eligible for the tax rebates.” Manufacturers announced adjustments to EV production and sales strategies to meet the current market circumstances and buyers’ affordability, she said. Tesla sped up the rollout of its new line of cheaper EVs , the company said during its earnings report. The company posted its weakest quarterly financial results in years in Q1 amid slowed sales growth. Mercedes-Benz executives said they are expecting plug-in hybrid electrics to “play an important role” in current market conditions. The company overall saw a decline in EV sales by about 2% year on year, driven by a drop of approximately 4,000 BEV sales, or an 8% drop, according to the company’s Q1 results. Meanwhile, PHEV sales increased by about 3,000, or 6%. North American lithium supply The bullish PHEV trend in the US could lend further support to North America’s burgeoning upstream battery metal supply chain, which saw positive updates to project developments announced at the end of Q1 and into the second quarter. For instance, Sayona Mining said in April it would continue the operational ramp-up of lithium-bearing spodumene concentrate production at its North American Lithium asset in Quebec after completing a strategic review that initially put the project’s near-term future in doubt due to declining lithium prices. NAL is the continent’s only operating spodumene mine. In the US, Ioneer said April 15 that construction activities could begin at its Rhyolite Ridge lithium mining project in Nevada by the end of the year, with potential production start up in 2027, if it receives approval through the US Bureau of Land Management’s Environmental Impact Statement. Lithium Americas also received a conditional commitment from the US Department of Energy in March for a $2.26 billion loan that, if successfully closed, would cover most of the remaining capital needed to start major construction of the Thacker Pass lithium project in Nevada by the end of the year. Regarding North American EV production capacity, Honda now plans to build multiple facilities in Ontario by 2028 that will include the production of EVs, batteries and certain battery materials, thus establishing ownership of its own midstream and downstream EV battery supply chain in the Canadian province, the Japanese automaker said April 25. Platts Connect: News & Insights (spglobal.com)